It's OK. Obviously they win on BD/HDDVD playback at present, mainly from lack of competition. They have the best h264 decoder around. There are also nice control options over deinterlacing, so you can select specific modes - even hardware deinterlacing without acceleration (useful if your graphics card is maxxed out). They also use EVR nowadays, so in Vista there are no more tearing or weird colour problems. Still, if you exclude the proprietary/copyright factors limiting the number of BD/HDDVD players, most of the above can be done with the likes of MPC. Use the Cyberlink codecs and EVR, and you get the same picture.